Who would have thought that one Twitch chat message would bring back a 2020 controversy? While streaming recently on 4th April, Pokimane replied to an old remark made by the creator Jasontheween it appeared to be protecting Fedmyster , a previous member of OfflineTV who was expelled from the group following significant allegations.
Indeed, the Fedmyster controversy—which sent shockwaves through the Twitch community in 2020—is once again making headlines. This time around, however, it’s not just about attracting clicks with sensational content. Instead, it marks a return of unresolved conflicts that initially split audiences, streamers, and even personal relationships apart.
Sure, let’s delve into the 2020 Fedmyster controversy. Fedmyster, whose actual name is Federico Michael Gaytan, was removed from OfflineTV following allegations made by multiple women, including Pokimane and Yvonne , charged him with behaving improperly. This included unwelcome physical contact and manipulative actions at the creator's residence.
OfflineTV released an official statement at that time, followed by Fedmyster publishing a detailed 25-page defense of his position later, which escalated the dispute even further. The situation became highly charged and split opinions, leaving a significant mark on Twitch’s community dynamics.
Here’s a clip where Pokimane discusses Fedmyster getting removed and shares her perspective on the situation:
The 2020 Fedmyster Controversy: An Overview
The Fedmyster controversy erupted halfway through 2020 when members of the OfflineTV team issued an official announcement stating that Fedmyster had been removed from the group because of alleged misconduct. Thesportsrush Yvonnie and Pokimane, key figures in the group, later released public statements detailing their direct experiences with his inappropriate behavior behind closed doors, despite having resided together at the OfflineTV house.
Yvonne recounted several instances where Fed allegedly entered her room late at night unannounced and climbed into her bed without consent. Pokimane added that Fed caused her to question the individuals living with them, which led to distrust and conflict among the group. Other members of OfflineTV supported these claims, presenting a unified stance to justify distancing themselves from him.
Also Read: "Rich kid, move out." The internet buzzes over Pokimane's enigmatic social media update suggesting her departure from Los Angeles.
The 25-page Google Doc along with Fedmyster's input
Several months following the allegations, Fedmyster released a detailed 25-page Google doc aimed at sharing his perspective on the situation. This document included images of previous chats, chronological charts, and explanations of his understanding of the incidents. While acknowledging mistakes on his part, he also maintained that certain aspects had been misrepresented.
Even though his intention may have been to clear things up, the document sparked yet another wave of anger. Most viewers and creators saw it as an attempt to take over the story or undermine the experiences of those involved. This letter reignited public curiosity about the controversy, pulling OfflineTV back into the spotlight.
This report divided online communities. Many supported Fedmyster, whereas others intensified their backing for Pokimane, Yvonnie, and the rest of OfflineTV’s team. This controversy sparked extensive conversations across various platforms like Reddit, Twitter, and YouTube, cementing its place as one of the year’s most talked-about Twitch scandals.
The Twitch comment from Jasonthewein and Pokimane's response
In 2025, Pokimane revisited some old conversations and stumbled upon an archived Twitch comment from her peer, Jasontheween, which seemed supportive of Fedmyster during the height of the dispute.
She voiced his remark aloud,
"FED. U PLAYED FED."
She was startled by Jasontheween’s remarks and shouted,
Jason, I'm truly at a loss for words, buddy.
However, recognizing that Jasontheween has developed and evolved over the past several years, she included,
I must admit, seeing Jason progress from penning stuff like this to where he stands now truly shows development. He’s endearing; I pardon him, honestly, I couldn’t care less.
Tap to watch the Twitch broadcast.
Her reply created ripples across the internet. People debated whether Jasontheween’s comment was taken out of context or reflected an overarching viewpoint shared by some producers back in 2020. Some pointed out how much the atmosphere on Twitch and the landscape of content creation have changed since then, making comments like these more difficult to decipher today.
As the Twitch landscape continues to evolve rapidly, incidents such as those involving Fedmyster raise queries that do not have straightforward answers. Pokimane’s recent reaction stemmed from more than just an outdated chat comment; it served as a reminder of a distressing time that altered the fabric of a community.
Moreover, regardless of Jasontheween’s intentions at the time, the internet most definitely does not let things go—particularly when it involves drama that once divided an entire community.
Also read: "When do you want to tie the knot?": FaZe Kaysan returns after Pokimane mentions she's single.